PHYSICS, PHILOSOPHY, AND A GOD WHO IS STILL BECOMING
An Article. See also Richard Feynman, Carlo Rovelli, John Archibald Wheeler, and The Wave That Never Breaks.
The Paragraph That Says It All
Why this page exists
Back in March, before River of Dreams existed in its current form, I came across an essay on Medium by the physicist Tim Andersen, Ph.D., called “God the Quantum Mechanic.” I liked it so much I put it up on my personal site. Rereading it this fall, I realized it had been sitting in the wrong house all along. It belongs here, because one paragraph in it says what this whole site is trying to say better than I've managed to say it myself:
“In this way, physics is not that different from theology. But whereas theologians have great respect for philosophy, physicists have a tendency to treat it like a waste of time. This is even though all of the most fundamental concepts in physics: time, space, matter, causation, probability, measurement, observation, and even the concept that physics exists at all are based in philosophy.”
— Tim Andersen, Ph.D., “God the Quantum Mechanic”That's the River of Dreams premise in two sentences. Science and religion aren't opposing teams. They're both standing on the same foundation — philosophy — and they're both trying to answer the same question: what is this place, and what are we doing in it? Andersen opens his essay by admitting he's “only a humble physicist,” but that without philosophy, “physics is just shutting up and calculating.” I'm not a physicist at all. But I know exactly what he means.
What Andersen Argues
The essay in four movements
1. Every era of physics borrows a philosophy. For centuries, Western thought ran on Plato and Aristotle: a world of things, each with its own essential nature. Medieval theology was built on that foundation, and so, Andersen points out, was classical physics. Newton overthrew Aristotle's physics but kept his picture of the world as objects with natures, pushed around by forces while an absolute clock ticked in the background. That picture fit a God who stands outside time, unchanging, watching all of history at once.
2. Quantum physics broke the picture. Underneath the orderly world turned out to be indeterminacy, and the founders scrambled for a new philosophy to make sense of it. Bohr is often read as leaning on Kant: we never see things in themselves, only how they show up in our instruments. Heisenberg reached back to Aristotle's idea of potential: a wavefunction is a set of possibilities that becomes actual only when it's measured. Einstein refused both, holding to a universe already written, like a book we read one page at a time.
3. Feynman's diagrams point to a world of events. This is the heart of the essay, and the part I find most exciting. In quantum field theory, particles aren't stable things; they appear, transform and vanish. The diagrams Richard Feynman introduced to keep track of them don't show where a particle travels. Andersen compares them to subway maps: they don't tell you the route through space, only the stops along the way. What matters are the points where something happens.
“Consider that we only perceive the electron when we observe it, and to observe something, it has to, in field theory parlance, scatter off of something. In other words, we never see the lines in the diagrams. We only see the vertices.”
— Tim Andersen, Ph.D.From there, Andersen argues, the philosophy that fits modern physics best isn't one of things with properties, but one where events are all there is, and what we call objects are just strings of similar events in a row.
4. That philosophy already exists, and it has a theology. The mathematician and philosopher Alfred North Whitehead built exactly that picture in Process and Reality (1929): a universe made of momentary “actual occasions,” each one taking in its past, choosing among possibilities, and becoming something new. Whitehead called them “drops of experience.” Everything is becoming rather than being, including you and me. Theologians like John B. Cobb Jr. carried this into process theology, where God doesn't control events from outside time. God offers possibilities, “lures” toward greater good, and every event, from an electron to a human choice, is free to answer. God, in this view, persuades rather than commands, experiences the world along with us, and changes with it.
Andersen doesn't buy every move the process theologians make. He pushes back on those who reduce the resurrection to a symbol, and he sides with process thinkers like David Ray Griffin who argue that miracles fit the framework just fine. He closes with a question worth sitting with: will our understanding of God keep up with physics, or stay in the Middle Ages? And he warns of “a difficult tightrope to walk between updating our philosophy without throwing out everything in favor of a lukewarm scientism.”
Handle With Tongs
A few places where the details need care
Feynman wasn't a graduate student in 1948. The essay describes the inventor of the diagrams as “a Ph.D. student who had suspended his studies during WWII.” Feynman did put his thesis aside to work on the bomb project, but he finished his Ph.D. at Princeton in 1942, went on to Los Alamos, and was a professor at Cornell by the time he introduced the diagrams in 1948. They first appeared in print in 1949. It doesn't change Andersen's argument at all, but it's the kind of detail worth getting right. (His thesis adviser, by the way, was John Archibald Wheeler.)
Collapse theories are a minority view. Andersen points out that process philosophy fits best with interpretations of quantum mechanics in which wavefunctions really do collapse, like the GRW theory he describes, where possibilities spontaneously become actual “flashes.” GRW is a serious, testable proposal, but it's one of several, and many physicists prefer pictures in which nothing ever collapses at all. The page The Wave That Never Breaks makes that other case. The two pages disagree, and I think that's healthy: if the collapse theories are wrong, Whitehead's events need a different home in the physics.
“Drops of experience” isn't the same as consciousness. Andersen is careful about this, and it's worth repeating. Whitehead wasn't claiming that atoms think. “Experience” in his sense is something far more basic: taking in the past and responding to it. The label for this view, panexperientialism, was coined later by David Ray Griffin, the same process theologian Andersen cites on miracles.
Where It Meets the River
The river itself. This site is named for a river for a reason. Twenty-five centuries ago, Heraclitus is said to have taught that you can never step into the same river twice. Whitehead knew that lineage well. In Process and Reality he calls “all things flow” the first vague generalization that human intuition ever produced, and his whole philosophy is an attempt to make it precise. If Andersen is right, physics has been circling back to the same insight: the world isn't made of things that sit still. It's made of happenings.
Rovelli says it almost word for word. Carlo Rovelli titled a chapter of The Order of Time “The World Is Made of Events, Not Things.” His relational quantum mechanics says properties only exist in interactions, which is Andersen's “we only see the vertices” from another angle. It's the same idea behind Next Door Is a Relationship.
Wheeler and the participatory universe. John Archibald Wheeler insisted that no phenomenon is real until it is registered, and that we take part in bringing the universe into being. Whitehead's every event “choosing” its form, and Wheeler's universe built out of acts of observation, are cousins. Neither man would have been surprised to meet the other's idea.
Feynman, the reluctant philosopher. There's a nice irony in this one. On this site, Richard Feynman is the deliberate empiricist, the man who had little patience for philosophy. Yet Andersen argues that Feynman's own diagrams carry one of the most profound philosophical ideas in modern physics. Feynman might have rolled his eyes. The diagrams don't care.
Spooky action and the open future. In Spooky Action at a Distance, Bell's experiments showed that entangled particles don't carry a pre-written answer key; the answer comes into being when it's asked. That's exactly the kind of universe process philosophy needs: one where the future isn't already written.
And the gestalt. I'll never follow the mathematics of quantum field theory. But the National Gestalt was never about the math. It's about knowing enough to see the shape of the argument, and the shape here is beautiful: a physicist telling his colleagues that their equations already carry a philosophy, and a theologian's question waiting inside it.
The old picture gave us a clockwork universe and a clockmaker God who finished the job and stepped back. The picture Andersen sketches gives us something else: a universe still being written, one event at a time, and a God who is reading along with us — maybe even hoping, the way we do, for how the next page turns out.
Read the whole essay: Tim Andersen, Ph.D., “God the Quantum Mechanic” in The Infinite Universe on Medium (March 17, 2026; Medium members), also published on his Substack at timandersen.substack.com. There's a great deal more in the full piece than I've touched on here, including Feynman's original diagrams and Andersen's case for miracles, and it's worth your time. More of his writing is at medium.com/@andersentda.
— Robert J. Burtis
Compiled with AI assistance · Sources: Tim Andersen, Ph.D., “God the Quantum Mechanic” (Medium / Substack, 2026); Alfred North Whitehead, Process and Reality (1929); Carlo Rovelli, The Order of Time (2018); R.P. Feynman, “Space-Time Approach to Quantum Electrodynamics,” Physical Review (1949)