Dark Matter, the observer who chooses, and the TV series that could have been a River of Dreams page
My sister let me know the second season of Dark Matter was out on Apple TV, and I started the first episode that night. If you’ve spent any time on this site, you’ll understand why I’d been hoping for it. If there has ever been a television series built out of River of Dreams material, this is it: quantum superposition, the observer effect, many worlds, a mind that has to be quieted before it can see more, and underneath it all the oldest question there is. Of all the lives I might have lived, why this one?
A note before we go in: I’m going to keep this nearly spoiler-free. Everything below comes from the show’s setup, not its twists. The fun of it is in watching it unfold.
Jason Dessen (Joel Edgerton) teaches physics at a small college in Chicago. Fifteen years earlier he was a rising star in quantum research, until he chose a life with Daniela (Jennifer Connelly) and their son instead. He’s a good man with a good life, and he still wonders now and then about the road he didn’t take.
One night a masked stranger kidnaps him at gunpoint, asks him whether he’s happy with his life, and drugs him. Jason wakes up in a laboratory full of people who seem to know him, in a Chicago where he never married Daniela, never had a son, and went on to build the thing he once dreamed of. It’s called the Box.
The show was created by Blake Crouch from his 2016 novel of the same name. In an NPR interview when the book came out, Crouch said the story grew out of the choices “that can set us down one road or another,” and the trouble with them: “we don’t know that those choices in this moment will define the rest of our lives.”
The Box is a big steel cube, sealed off from the rest of the universe. Inside it, a person can exist in what physicists call superposition: in every possible state at once, the way Schrödinger’s famous cat is both alive and dead until someone opens the lid. In Dark Matter, the person in the box is the cat.
But there’s a catch, and it’s the part that made me sit up. As the show tells it, our own observing minds would collapse that superposition the moment we stepped inside, pinning us to one reality. So travelers take a drug that quiets the part of the brain that does the observing. Only then does the box open onto what lies beyond: a corridor of identical doors, stretching off into the dark, each one leading to a different version of the world.
And which world you find behind the door depends on what’s in your head when you open it: your thoughts, your fears, your longings. In Dark Matter, consciousness doesn’t just watch reality. It chooses it.
That drug stopped me cold, because it’s almost exactly what we wrote about just last week in “A Window, Not a Lamp.” That article explored an old idea from William James and Aldous Huxley: that the brain may not create consciousness at all, but filter it, narrowing a much larger awareness down to something we can live with day to day. Huxley called the brain a “reducing valve.” And brain-imaging studies have found that the networks tied to our everyday sense of self quiet down in deep meditation and under psychedelics, just as people report their awareness opening up.
Crouch’s drug does the same thing in fiction. It turns down the filter. Quiet the observer, and the narrow hallway of everyday reality becomes an endless corridor of possibilities. Call it coincidence if you like. For me, it was a little synchronicity, a TV show turning up right when I was already thinking these thoughts. Two of my Tributaries spent their lives exploring the same doorway in the real world: Robert Monroe, through out-of-body states, and Stanislav Grof, through psychedelic and breathwork experiences.
The show takes plenty of liberties, but its foundations come straight out of real quantum physics, and many of them are already on this site.
My take: that’s fair, and it’s why Dark Matter is a thriller, not a textbook. But the questions it dramatizes are the same ones serious physicists still argue about, and nobody has closed the door on them.
Strip away the physics and Dark Matter is about something every one of us has felt: the life we didn’t choose. The career we gave up, the person we didn’t marry, the city we didn’t move to. Jason gets to walk through those doors and meet the men he might have been.
Richard Bach got there first, in his 1988 book One. Richard and his wife Leslie take off in their seaplane and find themselves flying over a vast pattern of possible lives, meeting other versions of themselves who made different choices, some happier, some far sadder. Bach’s conclusion was that every choice we make really does create a world, and that we’re responsible for the ones we choose to live in.
It also echoes P.D. Ouspensky, who believed that time and possibility extend in more directions than we can see, and the idea from Flatland that our lives might be one slice of something much larger. Each door in Crouch’s corridor is one of those slices.
What I love most is where the show lands. Out of every possible world, what makes this one yours? It isn’t the physics. Jason isn’t trying to find the best world or the most successful version of himself. He’s trying to get home, to the people he loves. Which brings us back to the idea at the heart of “He Gives Us All His Love”: love is the river.
Season two premiered August 28, and all ten episodes are now out, so you can watch at your own pace. Apple describes the setup this way: the Dessens have settled into what seems like a safe life until unforeseen events force them to run again. Jason grows more obsessed with the Box, Daniela grows more paranoid, and Leighton, the man who paid for the Box, is pursuing his plan to build a “perfect world.” I’m only one episode in, so no spoilers from me. I’ll just say that a man trying to engineer the perfect reality sounds like a very River of Dreams kind of villain.
If you’ve never seen it, start with season one. It’s nine episodes, and it’s the best television I’ve seen on these ideas. And if quantum physics usually makes your eyes glaze over, don’t worry: the show is a gripping thriller and a love story first. The physics sneaks up on you.
Every choice is a door.